Cook Sinker Missing

LOS ANGELES – Shrug off Aaron Cook’s Opening Day struggle in Arizona. It was, after all, Opening Day, and the ball was carrying at Chase Field, as even the Diamondbacks could attest.
Last Sunday against Philadelphia, Cook may not have been Cook at his best, but on a frigid afternoon at Coors Field he was good enough to get a victory if the Rockies late-inning relievers hadn’t been so bad.
Saturday, against the Dodgers?
There’s no way to rationalize the mess.
The only thing keeping it from being a perfect afternoon was Cook, himself.
“Los Angeles in the day time?’’ said Cook. “It’s warm, You get a good sweat. You get good movement. It was as normal as it can get.’’
That is, it was as normal as it can get, except for the results.
For the second time in three starts, Cook’s sinker was missing. The Dodgers made him pay for it in a 9-5 Rockies loss in which only three of the 12 outs that Cook registered came on ground balls.
Heck, Cook even felt good.
“I wish I could put the blame on that, but physically, this is the best I have felt in a long time,’’ he said.
And that, he said, is a concern for Cook in particular, and the Rockies in general.
Cook is considered their ace, but he’s been trumped in all three starts so far this season.
And it is a puzzle. It’s one thing to not command pitches and not throw strikes. But to leave pitches up in the zone? That’s not Cook.
“It’s why this game makes you scratch your head sometimes,’’ said pitching coach Bob Apodaca. “sometimes things you take for granted turn out to be things you can’t control. We’ve got to sit down and determine the problem.’’
The numbers say there are plenty of problems.
Manny Ramirez hit two home runs off him on Saturday, and then Andre Ethier unloaded a three-run shot off Cook that made the score 5-0. Strange? Well, it is only the fifth time in Cooks career he has allowed three home runs in a game. And Ramirez is only the third player to hit two home runs in a game off Cook, the first to do it on the road.
Troy Glaus, then with Arizona, got him twice at Coors Field on Sept. 11, 2005, and on June 11, 2006, Matt Kemp of the Dodgers connected twice at Coors Field.
“His priority every time out is to establish the sinker,’’ said manager Clint Hurdle. “That’s No. 1 on his list. That did not happen (Saturday) and there was no Plan 2 or Plan 3.’’
There doesn’t normally need to be.
In the last four seasons, combined, Cook averaged 2.74 ground ball outs to baseball outs, fifth best in baseball in that stretch. He gave up an average .071 home runs per nine innings, second best ratio in the majors. And he averaged 1.31 grounded-into-double-plays per nine innings, second best in majors.
So far this year?
Well, he has registered 16 ground ball outs and 14 fly balls outs along with six strikeouts and an out on a sacrifice bunt. More concerning is in his 2 1/3 innings on Opening Day he had only two outs thanks to ground balls, and then on Saturday, only three of his 12 outs came on ground balls, and two of those were on the same ground ball, a first-inning double play.
Not only did Manny Ramirez hit two home runs off Cook, but with the Dodgers leading only 2-0, Andre Ethier unloaded a three-run shot that put the Dodgers on top 5-0.
Rare? Only two other times in Cook’s career did he give up two home runs to the same batter in a game and both those games were at Coors Field – Troy Glaus with St. Louis on Sept. 11, 2005, and Matt Kemp with the Dodgers on June 11, 2006. It’s only the 14th time in his career he’d even given up more than one home run in a game, and the fourth time he had given up three.
“We’ll come back in (on Sunday) and talk about what has happened,’’ said Apodaca. “Right now (after the game) it hurts. You are angry. All the emotions are popping up. It’s the beginning of the season, when you are so optimistic, and this happens.’’
It is a puzzle, but Cook knows there is a solution. He just has to find it.
“I need to keep moving forward,’’ he said. “I don’t want to dwell on it, but I need to look at it and fix it.’’

Interesting quotes from Cook and Apodaca. Cook will be just fine as the season moves along. Jimenez should be absolutely dominating tomorrow afternoon, then Marquis and Morales go in the desert while the Rockies will miss Haren if I have it calculated correctly.
If the Rockies can get through that stretch in good shape then it’s time to exact a little revenge on the Dodgers next weekend in Coors Field.
Correcting my previous post. – Just saw on the official site that Haren is scheduled to pitch for the D-backs Wednesday, but the Rockies get McDonald, Garland and Petit Sunday through Tuesday, all with ERAs at 8 or above, so time for the offense to get in gear!
The solution is it’s early. In two months Cookie will be the solution. It’s not last year.
Why is Cook tinkering with a breaking ball? He won 16 games last year living on his bread and butter, the sinker. He needs to go back to that.
Mr. Ringolsby:
I understand no one is saying there is a physical injury to Cookie.
However, given the problem with locating pitches up, e.g: not so much down or side to side, and that this has not consistently been an issue in the past, is there any good reason to believe there is not a shoulder issue?
I would say given he is not making a major adjustment in his delivery and arm angle and that he is building up a pitch count and not mentioning any type of phsyical problem, I have to trust that he is healthy and it is a mechcnial issue. I haven’t seen a major drop in velocity and struggles with command, which are usual tips of a labrum problem.
David, he used his four seam fastball last year, too, along with a breaking ball. He is working to have some otherlooks but the focus has been on his sinker.
maybe there’s another contributing factor that i don’t think anyone in this blog has written about. typically, sinker ball pitchers like cook need to work every 5 days to be a touch tired so they get better downward action. if you look back, cook’s last time to pitch before opening day was only 3 innings, by design. after opening day, it has been 6 days each time with all of the open dates in the schedule. guess what? it will be 6 days again this time since this coming thursday is an open date. there’s my theory and i hope it isn’t any more than that.
oh, by the way, give manny a little credit for his 2nd HR yesterday. our pitching staff had been trying to pitch him low and inside friday nite, and it worked. on saturday, he opened up and looked for a low inside pitch in his 2nd AB…..and dang it, it worked for him!!
Don, Excellent points.
Leave your response!
Recent Comments
More at Inside The Rockies
More around the Web
Newsroom
Blogroll
Archives